Is Hamilton throwing away its shot to reach the very people who influenced its music?
Anyone who knows me is aware that I am absolutely obsessed with the soundtrack for the hit Broadway musical Hamilton. Rarely do I have an entire soundtrack to a musical easily accessible in my iTunes library, but when I started listening to Hamilton, I knew that my feelings would soon change.
When I first heard about Hamilton, I didn’t believe the hype. I thought, “okay, great, they put a bunch of minorities on a stage to watch us sing and dance, what’s new?” I was unphased by the history this musical was making. It took my Theatre Histories I teacher assigning the Hamilton soundtrack as homework for me to fall head over heels in love with the musical and storyline. I was enthralled by Lin-Manuel Miranda’s lyricism and poignant storytelling through the score. The music is historically accurate yet refreshing and relatable.
Hamilton is a masterpiece.
But every masterpiece has its flaws. And Hamilton’s is accessibility.
The ticket prices for Hamilton are ridiculous. And every time I get an email from their website saying that there’s another block of tickets available, I get a bit excited and head to the website, only to be disappointed by the fact that these tickets are $400 or more. At this point, I’m just plain infuriated.
The main attraction of Hamilton, the reason it is so successful, is because the primary characters are played by black and Latinx actors and actresses who rap, and this changed the game of what a Broadway musical can be. So, yet again, America’s fixation on black and brown bodies and our culture is put on yet another stage to be looked at and admired by those who can afford it. And yet again, the very people who are part of the culture that Hamilton is built on, for the most part, aren’t able to see it and reap the benefits.
People will want to say that Hamilton is great because it’s showing black and Latinx kids, teenagers, and young adults that they too can be represented on a major stage. I pose the question: how? How is this possible when the very people Hamilton is supposed to be inspiring, for the most part, cannot afford to see the show even if they saved up for five months?
And let’s just take the race element out of it for a second. The only people able to see Hamilton are the wealthy and the lucky few who win the Hamilton lottery everyday. Incase everyone forgot, rap and hip-hop are the musical genres for the disenfranchised and the so-called bottom of the 99%. This is what Hamilton has gained its success for, yet the 99% has no chance of ever witnessing it until two to three years from now. Even if you’re not poor or struggling for money, $400 for just ONE Broadway ticket is a lot to pay.
I fear that Hamilton has taken a genre of music that wasn’t meant for the 1%, and it’s morphed into a breath-taking soundtrack they can understand and digest, yet it has locked out the very people the genre was made by and for . If ticket prices let us know anything, we know that Hamilton is not for the not-wealthy. It is not for the little black and Latinx children who want to be performers. It is not for those who don’t have the means to enjoy a show they can relate to. It is yet another example of America commodifying a culture and then blocking the very people of that culture out of it. And this isn’t Lin-Manuel Miranda’s fault – he wrote an amazing score, fantastic lyrics, and a comprehensive script that he maybe thought would resonate with those of immigrant backgrounds, those who America treats as lesser, those who America usually forgets. That’s what I get from Hamilton when I listen to the soundtrack, but those ideals sung about in the musical sadly do not transfer over in the real world.
Let me know your thoughts in the comments section below!
Ahtiya
I’m on Twitter (@_AhtiyaL_), Instagram (@_AhtiyaL_), and Facebook (Ahtiya L). Follow my accounts and like my Facebook page! And if you support the cause of promoting and showcasing bloggers and vloggers of color, follow Bloggers Of Color (@POCBloggerRT) on Twitter! Please and thank you!
Don’t forget to check back next week for another article!
Copyright 2017 Ahtiya Liles
I strongly disagree. Hip hop is an extremely successful industry with a global following. Just because it isn’t what you’re used to or enjoy, doesn’t dictate its right to its presence. Its okay for you not to have an interest in something thats personal. However, regardless of whether I like something or not I give credit where it’s due. Hip hop & it’s history has changed music the industry & society, through the messages it can send especially politically. Hip hop & rap should be more present if anything to provide representation, and opportunity for black and non black people of color to be casted. Your statement has been used even within the dance world on people thinking that ballet has to remain only one way and excluding the creation of hiplet. While it is not the “norm” these are spaces that are opening up to others and if anything that should be supported. Art is a beautiful and constantly evolving, to be exclusive is an injustice to it and it is not how art should function.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am a massive musical fan. But yet, have no interest in seeing Hamilton and that surprises many people. I am not a big fan of hip-hop or rap, which is why I do not want to see the musical. I feel like those two types of music do not belong in the musical world
LikeLike
Why do you think rap and hip-hop do not belong in the musical world?
LikeLike
Here’s the thing. I have never liked the two genres. I am so used to rap being gangster and violent. It is just hard to visualize the two in musicals
LikeLike
I think you should probably do a little research about rap and hip hip before making a generalization that wide and stereotypical about an entire genre, especially one that has specific roots tied directly to the culture of a group of people. And for the sections of rap and hip hop that are “gangster and violent,” maybe analyze why certain pieces within a genre that was created to be a reflection of a person’s circumstances are like that. If violence is what some people reflection in their music, what have they seen in their life that makes them internalize it and what are the circumstances that lead to this? I find that some see rap and hip-hop as gangster and violent but never stop to pause as to why that is. As someone who creates theatre, I see it as a reflection of society, and rap/hip-hop (and what it represents, what it talks about, and why it was created) is very much part of the daily reality for a large section of our society. Also, you should probably give the soundtrack to Hamilton a listen (it’s available on RapGenuis for free with lyrics as well) because your original statement doesn’t hold up for Hamilton’s music — Hamilton is very much a bridge and combination of the two: hip-hop/rap and typical Broadway show music. There’s nothing even remotely “gangster and violent” about the show.
Thank you for comment!
LikeLike
I tend to associate musical songs as theatrical
LikeLike
Great insight.
LikeLike